What books are like Payback's a Witch but spicier?

8 rated books share at least one trope with Payback's a Witch, which rates about 2/5, and each rates spicier on our 0–5 scale. The closest match is Things We Hide from the Light by Lucy Score.

1. 
   Things We Hide from the Lightby Lucy ScoreAlso slow burn and small town; spice 4/5
2. The Fiancé Dilemmaby Elena ArmasAlso slow burn and small town; spice 3/5
3. 
   Book Loversby Emily HenryAlso small town; spice about 3–4/5
4. 
   Shadow in the Emberby Jennifer L. ArmentroutAlso slow burn; spice about 4/5
5. 
   The Dareby Elle KennedyAlso slow burn; spice about 4/5
6. 
   Wicked Beautyby Katee RobertAlso competition; spice about 5/5
7. 
   Twisted Liesby Ana HuangAlso slow burn; spice about 5/5
8. 
   Things We Never Got Overby Lucy ScoreAlso small town; spice about 3–4/5

Picks share at least one trope with Payback's a Witch. They're listed by how closely their tropes match, counting the tropes either book has, then by popularity. Spice is on our 0–5 scale, and ratings marked "about" are estimates. Each book page lists the sources behind its ratings. How we rate